Barbara Hostetler was having triplets. And no one was more excited than wily grandma-to-be Freni. But when Barbara went into labor and only two were born, Freni couldn't accept that this was just a doctor's mistake. She insisted on a recount....

Now Freni wants innkeeper Magdalena Yoder to find the little one. Magdalena decides to humor her eccentric cook and start searching, but while questioning doctors and nurses, the strangest thing happens: Their stories don't add up. And the only one who seems to be making sense -- is Freni. Magdalena better find answers quick before the cradle robber strikes again....